We’ve all heard the saying ‘build a better mousetrap, and nature will build a better mouse’. Build a better kid-trap, and the kids will find a way of circumventing it that will leave the average adult scratching their head in the dark, wondering what the hell happened.
Which is why drug testing in schools won’t work. Jo Baxter from Drug Free Australia (tell her they’re dreaming) reckons
After implementing a student drug-testing program, Hunterdon Central Regional
High School in New Jersey saw a reduction in cocaine use by seniors from 13% to
4% after two years. Schools in Autauga County in Alabama experienced decreases
in marijuana use from 19% to 12%. In Indiana, 85% of schools saw an increase in
drug use when testing was suspended; drug use fell when testing resumed.
But she’s not as smart as the average coke-snorting kid. None of us is. That first statistic should read
After implementing a student drug-testing program, Hunterdon Central Regional
High School in New Jersey saw a reduction in detectable cocaine use by seniors
from 13% to 4% after two years.
If you ask me (and you did, since you’re reading my blog), all that testing means is that the kids are finding ways to out-wit the testing process. Buying baby urine from a pediatric nurse, like in American Beauty, perhaps. Or taking a masking substance. Or using other drugs that are harder to detect, or aren’t being tested for. Try getting LSD to show up on a drug test. Oh wait, it doesn’t.
But the thing I really, really want to know is about the increase in drug use in Indiana when testing was suspended. If testing was suspended, how did they know more kids were using drugs? By testing them, dear Henry, dear Henry, dear Henry. But testing’s suspended, dear Liza, dear Liza. Etc.
Jo Baxter’s Alice-in-wonderland style fantasy continues. “one significant benefit is the fact that successful models of school drug testing have provided valid reasons for students to legitimately say "no" when pressured to use drugs.”
Clearly Jo Baxter was never actually a teenager and sprung fully formed from an egg of some sort. Or possibly leapt from her father’s head, after he had a particularly bad headache for which he refused to take an aspirin. “Pressured” to take drugs – when does that actually happen? They showed us these fabulously snigger-worthy videos at school about how to “say no to drugs”, where people said things like “Oh go on, have one or you’re a dag”. It doesn’t happen in real life. Your peers aren’t going to overtly pressure you to take drugs because that means less for them. The pressure is much more subtle than that – not that I ever noticed it, because I was busy trying to get my hands on as many drugs as I could possibly purchase with my very limited pocket money – it’s the unspoken pressure to fit in with your peer group. Which I would say is a basic human drive, and not likely to be influenced by whether or not your school has a drug testing policy.
To be clear, I’m not for rampant teenaged drug use these days. For one thing, I’ve had my fun and as an old crank don’t see why anyone else should be allowed to have any. And for another thing, I saw several friends damaged pretty severely by their drug use, which revised my opinions on the whole legalise-everything-let’s-take-heaps-of-hallucinogens front. But neither am I for invading people’s civil liberties by subjecting them to unwanted drug testing (if they’re not endangering the lives of others - obviously drug/alcohol testing of drivers is a different kettle of fish). And teenagers, despite behaving to the contrary (and possibly all having a mental illness), are human beings with the same fundamental rights as the rest of us. As the Magna Carta said:
NO Freeman shall be taken or imprisoned, or be disseised of his Freehold, or
Liberties, or free Customs, or be outlawed, or exiled, or any other wise
destroyed; nor will We not pass upon him, nor condemn him, but by lawful
judgment of his Peers, or by the Law of the Land. We will sell to no man, we
will not deny or defer to any man either Justice or Right.
Also, no town or person shall be forced to build a bridge across a river. Just in case you were wondering.





